VETERANS HEALTH ADMINISTRATION CLINICAL PRACTICE GUIDELINE FOR THE MANAGEMENT OF COPD OR ASTHMA  
Outpatient Management of COPD: Initial Visit (A1)
 

A. Patient with Suspected or Established Diagnosis of COPD - Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) is defined by the American Thoracic Society (ATS) in Standards for the Diagnosis and Care of Patients with Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease (1995). Further detail on lung function testing is found in another ATS publication (1991).

 

B. Perform Clinical Assessment, History, Physical Examination, Lab Tests, and Spirometry

     

C. Stage COPD on the Basis of FEV1 as Mild, Moderate, or Severe - Grading or staging, based on severity of airflow obstruction, facilitates the application of clinical recommendations and attempts to offer a composite picture of disease severity. Forced expiratory spirometry is used in the diagnosis of COPD as well as in the assessment of its severity, progression, and prognosis. Once airflow limitation has been diagnosed by a reduction in FEV1:VC (vital capacity) or FEV1:FVC (forced vital capacity), the severity can be graded by the patient's percentage of predicted FEV1. Stages of mild, moderate, and severe as adopted in the 1995 ATS document are used in the attached Chronic COPD algorithm. The severe stage in the VA's COPD population (predominantly middle-aged and male) is usually determined by a reduction in the FEV1 below one liter. 

SEVERITY OF COPD BASED ON FEV1
 
Severity FEV1 ** Percent Predicted
Mild 50 to 79
Moderate 35 to 49
Severe < 35

**In the presence of obstruction assessed as a low FEVI :FVC or FEV1:VC ratio.

TABLE OF EVIDENCE
 
Intervention References Grade of Evidence Strength of Recommendation
Definition of COPD ATS 1991, 1995 

ERS, Siafakas 1995

Staging ATS 1995 

ERS, Siafakas 1995


*European Respiratory Society

D. Acute Exacerbation of COPD - Acute exacerbation is defined as a recent deterioration of the patient's clinical and functional state that is due to worsening of his or her COPD. Typical symptoms and signs of COPD exacerbation are listed below (adapted from the European Respiratory Society Consensus Statement, Siafakas, 1995):

E. Asymptomatic on Usual Daily Activities and FEV1 Below 50 Percent? - Client may exhibit symptoms of dyspnea and/or wheezing. Dyspnea may be at rest or disproportionate to the degree of breathlessness expected for a given activity.

F. If on Therapy, Reevaluate or Begin Trial of Therapy with Inhaled Anticholinergic (IAC) - A trial of IAC therapy is recommended in apparently asymptomatic patients with an FEV1 of less than 50 percent of predicted, since this degree of obstruction is usually associated with dyspnea. This is based on the well-known phenomenon of patients "adapting to their disability." Such a lack of symptoms may result from the patient's avoiding activities or simply thinking along the lines of "Doesn't everyone get short of breath doing this activity at my age?"

Ipratropium (without prn inhaled short-acting beta2-agonist, since it is not needed for rescue medication) is generally the first choice in a trial of therapy, with improvement in function or activities of daily living being used to guide therapy (See annotation G). If ipratropium is ineffective or produces a less-than-optimal effect, add a short-acting inhaled beta2-agonist on a regular schedule (i.e., not prn) as combination therapy. A long-acting inhaled beta2-agonist may be substituted for the short-acting inhaled beta2-agonist if usage warrants. For further details on use of ipratropium and beta2-agonists, see Pharmacotherapy Module A4. If there is no improvement or if symptoms worsen, the trial should be discontinued.

Ipratropium and short-acting inhaled beta2-agonist in typical doses (2 to 4 inhalations) on a scheduled rather than prn use are generally equally as effective as bronchodilators, although some studies suggest that ipratropium has a greater peak and a longer duration of action. The side effects of each are similar (except for increases in heart rate and tremor neither of which is typical at these doses) that occur almost exclusively with beta2-agonist. Dyspnea may be improved to a greater extent with an inhaled beta2-agonist. Some patients will have a response to one but not the other, so in any trial of therapy, both should be tried if improvement is not optimal with the first choice. There is evidence that ipratropium improves baseline pulmonary function (after withholding ipratropium for 6 to 12 hours) whereas beta2-agonist do not. 

TABLE OF EVIDENCE
 
Intervention References Grade of Evidence Strength of Recommendation
Baseline FEV1 and FVC increased within 90 days after ipratropium initiation. Rennard 1996 B 2a
Ipratropium 40 g qid or metaproterenol 1.5 mg qid by inhalation were equally efficacious and safe over a 90-day period. Tashkin 1986 A 1
No difference between 200 g albuterol and 40 g ipratropium in magnitude, but duration was 1 hour longer with ipratropium on day 85.  Combivent 1994 A 1
Ipratropium produced more and longer bronchodilation than did albuterol.  Braun 1989 B 2a
The distance walked was greater with 7 days of albuterol (180 g) or ipratropium (36 g ) qid; also dyspnea was less with albuterol. Blosser 1995 B 2a
Of 80 responsive patients in a group of 100, 16 responded only to albuterol, 17 responded only to ipratropium, and 47 responded to both. Nisar 1992 C 1

G. If on Therapy, Reevaluate and Use Pharmacotherapy Module A4 or Begin Short-Acting Inhaled Beta2-Agonist (SAIBA) 2 to 4 Puffs qid prn - Short acting inhaled beta2-agonist has a more rapid onset than inhaled anticholinergics. Documentation of the benefits of therapy (except for use of steroidssee Module A4, Annotation C) does not depend on measuring pulmonary function routinely (Pino-Garcia 1996).

Symptoms may improve without substantial improvement in FEV1, indicating that continuation of therapy does not depend on routine assessment with spirometry. For example, short-acting inhaled beta2-agonist and ipratropium can improve exercise performance without necessarily improving FEV1. Also, it may be difficult to reduce high-dose ipratropium, since such doses may be needed to improve exercise performance. Inhaled short-acting beta2-agonists can improve dyspnea, and the benefit may be related to this action. Short-acting inhaled beta2-agonists but not ipratropium increase the alveolar-arterial oxygen difference, and this may be a reason to decrease the dose of beta2-agonist in titrating a patient's medication.


TABLE OF EVIDENCE
 
Intervention References Grade of Evidence Strength of Recommendation
Terbutaline (2 puffs, 500 g) decreased breathlessness. Pino-Garcia 1996 B 2a
Pirbuterol and ipratropium produced similar increases in FEV1. Pirbuterol increased the [A-a] O2 difference.  Ashutosh 1995 B 1
Albuterol (270 g) decreased breathless-ness with exercise.  Belman 1996 B 1
A minimum of 160 g of ipratropium improved exercise performance. Ikeda 1996 B 2a

H. If on Therapy, Reevaluate and Use Pharmacotherapy Module A4 or Begin SAIBA 2 to 4 Puffs qid prn Plus IAC 2 to 6 Puffs qid - Initiation or addition of regularly scheduled ipratropium at 2 to 4 puffs qid combined with prn short-acting inhaled beta2-agonist is recommended if this step in the algorithm is reached.

Should symptoms not resolve, the short-acting inhaled beta2-agonist can be increased to regularly scheduled dosing qid, with additional prn dosing for rescue. The typical dose is 2 to 4 inhalations, not to exceed 12 per day. However, as much as 1 mg of albuterol (or the equivalent of other short-acting beta2-agonists) may be required acutely to provide maximal bronchodilation for rescues.

The side effects include tremor, increase in heart rate, and reduced arterial oxygen saturation. When SAIBA is used as rescue medication, doses that are generally considered large (up to 10 inhalations) when used over a short time (minutes) may be necessary to alleviate acute shortness of breath or wheezing. In such cases, patients should seek medical advice to determine whether other measures are needed (see also Module A3, Acute Exacerbation).


TABLE OF EVIDENCE
 
Intervention References Grade of Evidence Strength of Recommendation
Metaproterenol inhalation (5 puffs) led to an improve-ment in the 12-minute walk that was not present with placebo. Results of spirometry were not improved.  Berger 1988 C 1
Significant dose-related improvement in spirometry with inhaled albuterol. One mg as a single dose offered most benefit versus side effects. Vathenen 1988 B 1
Average dose of albuterol inhalation for optimal improvement was 430 g (range up to 800 g) and for terbutaline was 1,160 g (range up to 2.5 mg). Jaeschke 1993 B 1

Should client requirements for ipratropium and inhaled short acting beta2-agonist dictate, regularly scheduled combination therapy is effective in usual doses of ipratropium and inhaled beta2-agonist. As the dose of ipratropium or inhaled short acting beta2-agonist increases, the added benefit becomes less from the other agent, but some patients will have an added benefit even with high doses of each. There is no way to predict, other than in a trial of therapy, which clients will have this combined effect.

Some patients can be maintained on a regularly scheduled short-acting inhaled beta2-agonist and ipratropium, such as 2 to 4 puffs of each four to five times a day.

Should the number of inhalations of short-acting beta2-agonist exceed 12 per day (the usually recommended maximum dose), the addition of long-acting inhaled beta2-agonist is recommended (see Pharmacotherapy Module A4). Short-acting inhaled beta2-agonist is continued as prn rescue medication.

The sequence of administration of ipratropium and short-acting inhaled beta2-agonist does not generally make any difference in the bronchodilator benefit.


TABLE OF EVIDENCE
 
Intervention References Grade of Evidence Strength of Recommendation
80 g ipratropium plus 400 g albuterol was better than 40 or 80 g ipratropium plus 200 g albuterol in improving FEV1. Ikeda 1995 B 1
There was no added benefit of doubling the ipratropium dose or adding 1,300 g of inhaled metaproterenol. Two of 12 patients benefited from this combination.  LeDoux 1989 B 1
40 g ipratropium plus 200 g inhaled albuterol yielded a greater increase in pulmonary function than did either 40 g ipratropium or 200 g albuterol. Combivent 1994 A 1
120 g of ipratropium or 800 g of albuterol give maximal bronchodilation in a single doses. Some patients may benefit from combination. Easton 1986 B 1
200 g ipratropium added to 5 mg terbutaline or 500 g terbutaline added to 200 g ipratropium improved pulmonary function.  Newnham 1993 C 1
 

If symptoms do not resolve, 6 and possibly 8 puffs of ipratropium may be needed qid. Improvement in pulmonary function is maximal at 6 to 14 puffs of ipratropium. Improvement in exercise performance generally requires a minimum of 6- to 8-puffs (108 to 144 g).


TABLE OF EVIDENCE
 
Intervention References Grade of Evidence Strength of Recommendation
Between 6 and 14 puffs of ipratropium (240 g) produced maximum increase in pulmonary function. Ikeda 1995 B 1
160 g of ipratropium was needed to give maximum benefit in pulmonary function and to give any benefit at all with exercise.  Ikeda 1996 B 1
0.4 mg of nebulized ipratropium provided a maximum response in pulmonary function. Suggested this was equivalent to 160 g from MDI.  Gross 1989 B 1
 
 

I. Does the Patient Have Symptoms of Sleep Apnea?

 
TABLE OF EVIDENCE
 
Intervention References Grade of Evidence Strength of Recommendation
COPD clients do not normally have EDS, even with nocturnal desaturation.  Orr 1990 C 2a

J. Initiate Preventive Care and Patient Education
TABLE OF EVIDENCE
 
Intervention References Grade of Evidence Strength of Recommendation
Pneumococcal vaccination. 

Most studies show an advantage, but one small randomized, placebo-controlled trial did not.

CDC ACIP 1997 

Fine 1994 

Shapiro 1984, 1991 

Farr 1995 

Sims 1988 

Forrester 1987 

Simberkoff 1986 


 
 
 
 
2a 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Annual influenza vaccination. CDC ACIP 1997 

Govaert 1994 

Nichol 1994 

Gross 1988 

Fedson 1993 

Foster 1992 


 
 
Smoking cessation slows lung function decline. Anthonison 1994 

Xu 1992 

Camilli 1987 

Fletcher 1977 

   
TABLE OF EVIDENCE
 
Intervention References Grade of Evidence Strength of Recommendation
Nutritional counseling ATS 1995 

Wilson 1986

2b 
Pulmonary rehabilitation Goldstein 1994 

ATS 1995

2a 
 

K. Be Aware of Precautions and Recommendations for Use of Medications and Aerosols
 

    2. Precautions when Using Theophylline
      3. Precautions when Using Ipratropium
      4. Precautions when Using Oral Steroids
      5. Precautions when Using Aerosol Steroids
     
    TABLE OF EVIDENCE

    Intervention References Grade of Evidence Strength of Recommendation
    Precautions when using pharmacotherapy. ATS 1995 C 1

    6. Recommendation - The fewest inhalers with the fewest inhalations at the least frequent interval consistent with a client's inhaler needs should be used to improve compliance. A similar principle applies to oral medications.

    7. Recommendation - MDI with, if necessary, a spacer is preferred unless not recommended by manufacturer; a hand-held nebulizer should be used only if client unable to use an MDI.
Nebulizers generally require between 2 and 12 times as much beta2-agonist to produce the same effect as an MDI, depending on the nebulizer used. Adherence with nebulizers is similar to that with MDI. There is no obvious advantage in using a nebulizer in a stable COPD client who can properly use an MDI.

TABLE OF EVIDENCE

Intervention References Grade of Evidence Strength of Recommendation
52 percent used MDI once daily or less rather than the required three times daily. Rand 1995 C 1
Adherence with intermittent positive pressure breathing (IPPB) or nebulizers was 50.6 percent. Turner 1995 C 1
Maximum bronchodilation similar between nebulizer and MDI beta2-agonist. Nebulizer dose twice MDI dose to produce same effect. Mestitz 1989 B 1
Dose of nebulized albuterol produced the same bronchodilation in any of peak expiratory flow rate, FEV1, or forced vital capacity was about 10 times higher than with MDI. Jenkins 1987 B 1
No difference in outcome between nebulizer and MDI. Nebulized metaproterenol dose was about seven times higher than with the MDI. Turner 1988 B 1
It took about 12.5 times as much nebulized albuterol to achieve the same increase in FEV1 as with MDI. Harrison 1983 B 1
 

L. Follow-Up as Indicated, Including Education - For mild COPD, spirometry is the test used for measuring disease progression. As the disease becomes more severe, oximetry and ABG assume greater importance. The frequency of obtaining these measures is based on clinical symptoms and status. In general, patients with mild COPD should be seen annually; moderate COPD, 6 months to 1 year, depending upon status; and severe COPD, every 6 months at a minimum. 


Intro | Table of Contents | Module A2