1. Definitions
a. Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) is a disorder characterized by the presence of airflow obstruction due to chronic bronchitis or emphysema; the airflow obstruction is generally progressive, may be accompanied by airway hyperreactivity, and may be partially reversible.
b. Chronic bronchitis is defined as the presence of chronic productive cough for 3 months of each of two successive years in a patient in whom other causes of chronic cough have been excluded.
c. Emphysema is defined as abnormal permanent enlargement of the air spaces distal to the terminal bronchioles, accompanied by destruction of their walls and without obvious fibrosis.
d. Asthma is by definition associated with reversible airflow obstruction. Patients with asthma whose airflow obstruction is completely reversible are not considered to have COPD. The obstruction in many patients with COPD may include a significant reversible component. Some patients with asthma may develop irreversible airflow obstruction indistinguishable from COPD.
2. Characterization of COPD
(2) Environmental (chronological) - May disclose important risk factors
(3) Cough (chronic, productive) - Frequency and duration, whether or not productive (especially on awakening)
(4) Wheezing
(5) Acute chest illnesses - Frequency, productive cough, wheezing, dyspnea, fever
(6) Dyspnea
b. Physical Examination of Chest
d. Laboratory
(2) Spirometry (pre- and postbronchodilation) - Essential to confirm presence and reversibility of airflow obstruction and to quantify maximum level of ventilatory function (ATS 1995)
(3) Lung volumes - Measurement of more than forced vital capacity is not necessary except in special circumstances (e.g., presence of giant bullae)
(4) Carbon monoxide diffusing capacity - Unnecessary except in special instances (e.g., dyspnea out of proportion to severity of airflow limitation)
(5) Arterial blood gases are not needed in staged mild disease, but remain the standard for determining the need for oxygen therapy
(6) Alpha1-antitrypsin (AAT) - AAT deficiency accounts for < 1 percent of COPD. Obtain a serum AAT level to screen for AAT deficiency in the following situations:
Ipratropium and short-acting inhaled beta2-agonists in typical doses (2 to 4 inhalations) on a scheduled rather than prn use are generally equally effective as bronchodilators, although some studies suggest that ipratropium has a greater peak and a longer duration of action. The side effects of each are similar, except for increases in heart rate and tremor (neither of which is typical at these doses) occur almost exclusively with beta2-agonists. Dyspnea may be improved to a greater extent with inhaled beta2-agonist. Some patients will have a response to one but not the other, so in any trial of therapy, both should be tried if improvement is not optimal with the first choice. There is evidence that ipratropium improves baseline pulmonary function (after withholding ipratropium for 6 to 12 hours) whereas beta2-agonists do not.
| Intervention | References | Grade of Evidence | Strength of Recommendation |
| Baseline FEV1 and FVC increased with 90 days after ipratropium initiation. | Rennard 1996 | B | 2a |
| Ipratropium 40 g qid or metaproterenol 1.5 mg qid by inhalation were equally efficacious and safe over a 90-day period. | Tashkin 1986 | A | 1 |
| No difference between 200 g albuterol and 40 g ipratropium in magnitude, but duration was 1 hour longer with ipratropium on day 85. | Combivent 1994 | A | 1 |
| Ipratropium produced more and longer bronchodilation than did albuterol. | Braun 1989 | B | 2a |
| The distance walked was greater with 7 days of albuterol (180 g) or ipratropium (36 g ) qid; also dyspnea was less with albuterol. | Blosser 1995 | B | 2a |
| Of 80 responsive patients in a group of 100, 16 responded only to albuterol; 17 responded only to ipratropium; and 47 responded to both. | Nisar 1992 | C | 1 |
C. Patient on Maximum Steroids with SRT, LAIBA, SAIBA, IAC - If no contraindications, oral steroids can be used (40 to 60 mg/day) for 2 to 3 weeks with remeasure of FEV1. If response, continue qod and decrease to lowest effective dose, with institution of high-dose inhaled steroids (HDIS) as part of the taper, with the ultimate goal of the lowest effective dose of inhaled steroids. An alternative is HDIS (see table on doses below) with measurement of FEV1 after 2 to 3 weeks; if less-than-optimal response, add oral steroids, with eventual adjustment to lowest effective dose or stopping of steroids if not effective.
A response is defined as one of the following:
Measurement of peak expiratory flow rate by patients at home, at least in the morning and at night, can be used to follow progress of treatment, since many investigators measured daily home PEF and found that it was higher with oral or inhaled steroids than on placebo.
Oral steroids can improve pulmonary function in patients with COPD. The number of patients who improve placebo-controlled studies is not presently precisely defined but appears to be in the 10 percent range, with some studies showing no improvement over placebo and other studies having as much as 38 percent of patients who have a 20-percent or more increase in FEV1 over baseline. The increase is determined by dividing the difference between posttreatment and pretreatment FEV1 (in liters) by the pretreatment value and multiplying by 100. The dose is from 30 to 80 mg of prednisone or equivalent every day or every other day, although two cohort studies suggest that long-term use (years) may be effective with doses as low as 10 mg/day of prednisolone or the equivalent. Every-other-day oral steroids appear to be as effective as daily oral steroids in stable COPD clients. Many patients with a response to oral steroids have a dramatic response (> 50 percent) that almost never occurs with placebo.
Inhaled steroids produce significant improvement in pulmonary function compared to placebo in a number of patients. The percent who improve is not precisely defined. The dose of inhaled steroids is important, with doses greater than 800 g/day of budesonide or beclomethasone being necessary to produce improvement in groups of COPD patients. Several long-term studies (2 years of inhaled steroid treatment) show a reduction in the decline in FEV1, fewer symptoms, and fewer dropouts with medium- (800 g/day) to high-dose (1,600 g/day) inhaled steroids. Response to high-dose inhaled steroids is predictive of response to oral steroids and inhaled steroids can be used as initial steroid therapy, with addition of oral steroids if there is a partial response.
Patients with predominant emphysema appear to respond as well or nearly as well as those with predominant chronic bronchitis.
It may take more than 2 weeks to determine responsiveness to either oral or inhaled steroids.
Patients with a response to inhaled beta2-agonists prior to the use of steroids may be more likely to respond to oral or inhaled steroids, but not all studies confirm this and the sensitivity and specificity are not sufficient in most studies to justify a decision to treat.
| Intervention | References | Grade of Evidence | Strength of Recommendation |
| Oral steroid meta-analysis: 10 percent of patients with COPD using oral steroids (30 to 80 mg/day or equivalent prednisone) had a 20 percent improvement in FEV1. | Callahan 1991 | A | 1 |
| Alternate-day oral steroids (64 mg) as effective as daily oral steriods (8 mg qid). | Blair 1984 | A | 1 |
| > 7.5 mg/day oral prednisolone slows decline of FEV1 and improves survival in severe COPD. | Postma 1985 | C | 2a |
| > 7.5 mg/day oral prednisolone decreases decline in FEV1 in moderately severe COPD. | Postma 1988 | C | 2a |
| 40 mg/day of prednisolone added to inhaled beclomethasone of 1,500 and 3,000 g/day did not further improve pulmonary function. | Weir 1993 | A | 2a |
| It can take more than 2 weeks to reach maxi-mum benefit from oral (40 mg prednisolone) or inhaled (1,500 g beclomethasone) steroids. | Weir 1990 | A | 1 |
| Intervention | References | Grade of Evidence | Strength of Recommendation |
| Emphysema and nonemphysema COPD respond similarly to oral prednisolone (40 mg/day) and inhaled beclomethasone (1,500 g/day). | Weir 1991 | B | 1 |
| 20 of 100 subjects responded to 30 mg prednisolone for 2 weeks, 17 of whom responded to ipratropium or albuterol and 3 of whom were nonresponders. | Nisar 1992 | C | 1 |
| Inhaled beclomethasone (1,500 g/day) produced 2/3 the response
of oral prednisolone.
Response to oral correlated with response to inhaled steroid. |
Weir 1990 | A | 2a |
| Response to high-doses inhaled beclomethasone (1,500 g/day) predicts which patients will respond to oral prednisoloine (30 mg/day). | Wardman 1988 | C | 2a |
| Addition of oral prednisolone (30 mg/day) produces further improvement in responders to inhaled beclomethasone (1,500 g/day). | Wardman 1988 | C | 2a |
| Meta-analysis: More than 800 g of inhaled beclomethasone or budesonide was required for improvement in pulmonary function or symptoms. | Van Schayck | A | 2a |
| Two years of 800 g/day of budesonide plus either albuterol or ipratropium reduced the decline in FEV1 and improved symptoms. | Dompeling 1993 | C | 2a |
| 800 g/day of budesonide for 12 weeks decreased cough but did not improve any other measure or symptom. | Engel 1989 | B | 2a |
| Two years of budesonide at 1,600 g/day improved symptoms, and there were fewer dropouts for pulmonary reasons compared to placebo. | Renkema 1996 | A | 2a |
| Six weeks of 800 g/day of budesonide improved 5 of 8 beta2-agonist acute responders and 1 of 22 nonresponders to beta2-agonist. | Weiner 1995 | B | 2a |
| Inhaled Steroid | Dose per Inhalation in g (Dose from Actuator before Mouthpiece) | Maximum Number of Inhalations per Day (PDR) | Number of Inhalations per Day for High-Dose Steriod per NAEPP, Expert Panel Report 2 | Comments | Number of Inhalations per Canister |
| Triamcinolone | 200 (100 with spacer) | 16 | > 20 | Built-in spacer. | 240 |
| Flunisolide | 250 | 8 | > 8 | Spacer can be used. | 100 |
| Beclomethasone | 50 | 20 | > 20 | Spacer can be used. | 200 |
| Beclomethasone | 100 | 10 | > 10 | Spacer can be used. | 120 |
| Fluticasone | 50 | 40 | > 12 | Spacer can be used. | 60-120 |
| Inhaled Steroid | Dose per Inhalation in g (Dose from Actuator before Mouthpiece) | Maximum Number of Inhalations per Day (PDR) | Number of Inhalations per Day for High-Dose Steriod per NAEPP, Expert Panel Report 2 | Comments | Number of Inhalations per Canister |
| Fluticasone | 125 | 16 | > 6 | Spacer can be used. | 120 |
| Fluticasone | 250 | 8 | > 3 | Spacer can be used. | 120 |
| Budesonide | 200 | 8 | > 3 | Spacer cannot be used and is not needed. Delivery system is base power without propellant. | 200 |
D. Consider Adding Sustained-Release Theophylline - Sustained-release theophylline (SRT) can be added to improve pulmonary function, symptoms, or activities. The blood level of theophylline should be measured, with a therapeutic target of 10 g/ml (range of 5 to 12 g/ml). If the theophylline level is difficult to regulate, if adverse symptoms occur, or if there is significant preexisting cardiovascular disease, avoid use.
Theophylline is a bronchodilator and improves symptoms. Combination therapy with a short-acting inhaled beta2-agonist provides added improvement. Theophylline may improve mucociliary clearance in the airways, may improve respiratory muscle strength, and may improve right ventricular and left ventricular ejection fraction, decrease pulmonary artery pressure, and increase heart rate.
| Intervention | References | Grade of Evidence | Strength of Recommendation |
| Theophylline is usually a bronchodilator. | Fragoso 1993 | A | 1 |
| Mucociliary clearance improved in some patients. | Fragoso 1993 | C | 2a |
| Some patients have an improvement in respiratory muscle performance. | Fragoso 1993 | B | 2a |
| Generally consistent improvement in function of the right heart. | Fragoso 1993 | C | 2a |
In some cases, if benefit has been demonstrated and with careful monitoring under guidance of a specialist, a blood level of 15 g/ml of theophylline can be a therapeutic target.
If the theophylline level is difficult to regulate, if adverse symptoms occur, or if there is significant preexisting cardiovascular disease, avoid use.
Theophylline levels of 14 mg/L or higher improve pulmonary function, decrease dyspnea, improve exercise, improve PaO2, decrease gas trapping, may decrease PaCO2, and have no obvious deleterious effects on sleep. Theophylline levels around 10 mg/L usually improve pulmonary function and arterial blood gases while awake or asleep and consistently improve exercise performance without impairing cognitive function. Attempts to withdraw theophylline, even at lower levels, should be done cautiously, since deterioration in pulmonary function and exercise performance may occur, with more shortness of breath, more wheezing, and more symptoms. Theophylline is a stimulant, and some patients have difficulty sleeping; however, in moderate to severe COPD, the overall effect is negligible and may even be beneficial, perhaps by reducing nocturnal symptoms from dyspnea, wheezing, and arterial oxygen desaturation.
| Intervention | References | Grade of Evidence | Strength of Recommendation |
| Two months of theophylline at 14.8 g/ml led to less dyspnea, an increase in PaO2, a decrease in PaCO2, and an increase in vital capacity and FEV1. | Murciano 1989 | A | 2a |
| Pulmonary function and exercise performance were improved on 9.5 mg/L of theophylline. | Newman 1994 | B | 2a |
| 17 mg/L improved pulmonary function and symptoms. | McKay 1993 | B | 2a |
| Withdrawal of theophylline (11 mg/L) led to a decline in pulmonary function, an increase in symptoms, and less distance in the 6-minute walk test. | Kristen 1993 | A | 2a |
| Theophylline at 12.2 mg/L improved FVC, MVV, and exercise. | Fink 1994 | B | 2a |
| Higher awake PaO2, lower awake PaCO2, higher sleep SaO2, improved FEV1, and lower trapped gas volume were seen with a theophylline level of 11.8 mg/L. | Mulloy 1993 | B | 2a |
| Theophylline (14.2 mg/L) improved FEV1; SaO2 increased during non-rapid eye movement (NREM) sleep. There were fewer arousals; sleep architecture was unaffected. | Berry 1991 | B | 2a |
| Twice-a-day theophylline (15 g/ml) improved FEV1 more than once a day (11/ml). No effect on arterial saturation or sleep architecture. | Martin 1992 | B | 2a |
| Theophylline (9.2 mg/ml) improved pulmonary function, reduced nocturnal wheezing, and improved nocturnal saturation. Sleep quality unaffected. | Man 1996 | B | 2a |
Combination therapy of theophylline, a short-acting inhaled beta2-agonist, and ipratropium can be used to improve pulmonary function and possibly symptoms.
Theophylline (12.5 to 15 g/ml) improves pulmonary function when used
in combination with short-acting inhaled beta2-agonists and ipratropium.
Symptomatic improvement may not occur.
| Intervention | References | Grade of Evidence | Strength of Recommendation |
| Theophylline (12.5 mg/L) significantly improved FEV1 and PEF (daily) to a small degree, even after the inhalation of salbutamol and ipratropium. | Nishimura 1993 | B | 2a |
| In combination with 400 g salbutamol qid and 80 g ipratropium qid, theophylline (15 mg/L) had a small additive effect on FEV1 and PEF. | Nishimura 1995 | B | 2a |
| Theophylline (12.9 mg/L) and salbutamol improved pulmonary function; the combination was better than either alone. | Thomas 1992 | B | 2a |
| Combination theophylline (12 to 18 mg/L), albuterol, and ipratropium improved pulmonary function more than did theophylline and albuterol or ipratropium alone. | Karpel 1994 | A | 2a |
Use of oral beta2-agonist in COPD has not been studied to a significant degree with respect to pulmonary function. However, one well-done study in a small number of subjects suggests that there is substantial additive effect when combinated with theophylline.
| Intervention | References | Grade of Evidence | Strength of Recommendation |
| No improvement in FEV1 or sleep stages with controlled-release albuterol. | Veale 1994 | B | 2a |
| Combination of slow-release aminophylline and oral (not slow-release) albuterol is a better bronchodilator than either alone. | Leitch 1981 | B | 2a |
Should symptoms not resolve, the short-acting inhaled beta2-agonist can be increased to regularly scheduled dosing qid, with additional prn dosing for rescue. The typical dose is 2 to 4 inhalations, not to exceed 12 per day. However, as much as 1 mg of albuterol (or the equivalent of other short-acting beta2-agonists) may be required acutely to provide maximal bronchodilation for rescue.
The side effects include tremor, increase in heart rate, and reduced arterial oxygen saturation. When SAIBA is used as rescue medication, doses that are generally considered large (up to 10 inhalations) when used over a short time (minutes) may be necessary to alleviate acute shortness of breath or wheezing. In such cases, patients should seek medical advice to determine whether other measures are needed (see also Module A3, Acute Exacerbation).
| Intervention | References | Grade of Evidence | Strength of Recommendation |
| Metaproterenol inhalation (5 puffs) led to an improvement in the 12-minute walk that was not present with placebo. Spirometry was not improved. | Berger 1988 | C | 1 |
| Significant dose related improvement in spirometry with inhaled albuterol. One mg as a single dose offered most benefit versus side effects. | Vathenen 1988 | B | 1 |
| Average dose of albuterol inhalation for optimal improvement was 430 mg (range up to 800 g) and for terbutaline was 1,160 g (range up to 2.5 mg). | Jaeschke 1993 | B | 1 |
Some patients can be maintained on a regularly scheduled short-acting inhaled beta2-agonist and ipratropium, 2 to 4 puffs of each four to five times a day.
Should the number of inhalations of beta2-agonist exceed 12 per day (the usually recommended maximum dose of inhaled short-acting beta2-agonist), addition of long-acting inhaled beta2-agonist is recommended (see Annotation F), with continuation of short-acting inhaled beta2-agonist as rescue medication.
The sequence of administration of ipratropium and a short-acting inhaled beta2-agonist does not generally make any difference in the bronchodilator benefit.
| Intervention | References | Grade of Evidence | Strength of Recommendation |
| 80 g ipratropium plus g 400 albuterol was better than 40 g or 80 g ipratropium plus 200 g albuterol in improving FEV1. | Ikeda 1995 | C | 1 |
| There was no added benefit of doubling the ipratropium dose or adding 1,300 g of inhaled metaproterenol. Two of 12 patients benefited from this combination. | LeDoux 1989 | B | 1 |
| 40 g ipratropium plus 200 g inhaled albuterol yielded a greater increase in pulmonary function than did either 40 g ipratropium or 200 g albuterol. | Combivent 1994 | A | 1 |
| 120 g of ipratropium or 800 g of albuterol gives maximal bronchodilation in a single dose. Some patients may benefit from combination. | Easton 1986 | B | 1 |
| 200 g ipratropium added to 5 mg terbutaline or 500 g terbutaline added to 200 g ipratropium improved pulmonary function. | Newnham 1993 | C | 1 |
Improvement in pulmonary function is maximal at 6 to 14 puffs of ipratropium.
Improvement in exercise performance generally requires a minimum of 6-
to 8-puffs (108 to 144 g).
| Intervention | References | Grade of Evidence | Strength of Recommendation |
| Between 6 and 14 puffs of ipratropium (240 g) produced maximum increase in pulmonary function. | Ikeda 1995 | B | 1 |
| 160 g of ipratropium is needed to give maximum benefit in pulmonary function and to give any benefit at all with exercise. | Ikeda 1996 | B | 1 |
| 0.4 mg of nebulized ipratropium provided a maximum response in pulmonary function. Suggested this was equivalent to 160 g from MDI. | Gross 1989 | B | 1 |
Salmeterol is an effective bronchodilator in patients with COPD at 50 micrograms bid. The degree appears to correlate with the amount of acute reversibility to short-acting inhaled beta2-agonists. Chronic dosing up to 16 weeks produces a benefit that does not diminish. Symptomatic improvement occurs with salmeterol as well as improvement in spirometry. The 100-microgram dose may not be effective in chronic dosing. Combination of usual doses of ipratropium with usual doses of salmeterol may not improve pulmonary function, suggesting that lack of improvement with the combination should not, in itself, prevent implementation of further therapeutic steps in patients responsive to at least one of ipratropium or salmeterol. Salmeterol decreases but does not eliminate prn short acting beta2-agonist rescue.
| Intervention | References | Grade of Evidence | Strength of Recommendation |
| Four weeks of 50 g bid salmeterol led to an increase in FEV1. | Grove 1996 | B | 1 |
| 16 weeks of treatment with 50 g bid salmeterol improved FEV1 and symptoms. | Jones 1997 | A | 1 |
| Salmeterol acute dose response curve plateaus at 50 g. | Cazzola 1995 | B | 1 |
| 4 weeks of 50 g bid salmeterol improved peak flow and symptoms. | Ulrik 1995 | A | 1 |
| Combination salmeterol (50 g) was no different than either alone for peak; duration was similar to that for salmeterol. | Matera 1996 | B | 2b |
Symptoms may be improved without substantial improvement in FEV1, indicating that continuation of therapy does not depend on routine assessment with spirometry. For example, short-acting inhaled beta2-agonists and ipratropium can improve exercise performance without necessarily improving FEV1. Also, it may be difficult to reduce high-dose ipratropium, since such doses may be needed to improve exercise performance. Inhaled short-acting beta2-agonists can improve dyspnea, and the benefit may be related to this action. Short-acting inhaled beta2-agonists but not ipratropium increase the alveolar-arterial oxygen difference and may be a reason to decrease the dose of beta2-agonists in titrating a patient's medication.
| Intervention | References | Grade of Evidence | Strength of Recommendation |
| Terbutaline (2 puffs = 500 g) decreased breathlessness. | Pino-Garcia 1996 | B | 2a |
| Pirbuterol and ipratropium produced similar increases in
FEV1. Pirbuterol increased the
[A-a] O2 difference. |
Ashutosh 1995 | B | 1 |
| Albuterol (270 g) decreased breathlessness with exercise. | Belman 1996 | B | 1 |
| A minimum of 160 g of ipratropium improves exercise performance. | Ikeda 1996 | B | 2a |
H. Be Aware of Precautions and Recommendations for Use of Medications and Aerosols
1. Precautions when Using Beta2-Agonists
| Intervention | References | Grade of Evidence | Strength of Recommendation |
| Precautions when using pharmacotherapy | ATS 1995 | C | 1 |
7. Recommendation - MDI with, if necessary, a spacer is preferred unless not recommended by the manufacturer; a hand-held nebulizer should be used only if the patient is unable to use an MDI.
Nebulizers generally require between 2 and 12 times as much beta2-agonist to produce the same effect as an MDI, depending on the nebulizer used. Adherence with nebulizers is similar to that with MDI. There is no obvious advantage in using a nebulizer in a stable COPD patient who can properly use an MDI.
| Intervention | References | Grade of Evidence | Strength of Recommendation |
| 52 percent used an MDI once or less daily rather than the required three times daily. | Rand 1995 | C | 1 |
| Adherence with intermittent positive pressure breathing (IPPB) or nebulizers was 50.6 percent. | Turner 1995 | C | 1 |
| Maximum bronchodilation was similar between nebulizer and MDI beta2-agonist. Nebulizer dose of twice MDI dose to produce same effect. | Mestitz 1989 | B | 1 |
| Dose of nebulized albuterol producing the same bronchodilation in any of peak expiratory flow rate (PEF), FEV1, or forced vital capacity (FVC) was about 10 times higher than with MDI. | Jenkins 1987 | B | 1 |
| No difference in outcome between nebulizer and MDI. Nebulized metaproterenol dose was about seven times higher than with the MDI. | Turner 1988 | B | 1 |
| It takes about 12.5 times as much nebulized albuterol to achieve the same increase in FEV1 as with an MDI. | Harrison 1983 | B | 1 |