VETERANS HEALTH ADMINISTRATION CLINICAL PRACTICE GUIDELINE FOR THE MANAGEMENT OF COPD OR ASTHMA  
Management of Asthma: Diagnosis - Initial Therapy (C1)

A. Patients with Cough, Wheeze, Shortness of Breath or Dyspnea Presenting to Primary Care - Initial/recurrent symptoms consistent with asthma include cough, wheeze, dyspnea, chest tightness, chest pain, sputum production.

B. Perform Assessment - Important components of medical history are exercise tolerance, respiratory infections, respiratory irritants, allergens/triggers, occupation and hobbies, family history of asthma or allergy, and active/passive smoke exposure. Important associated conditions are rhinitis, sinusitis, eczema, and gastroesophageal reflux.

Important additional historical components are severity of symptoms, limitations in lifestyle, emergency-room visits, hospitalizations, medication use, and environmental exposure.

The physical examination for asthma focuses on the upper airway, the chest, and the skin.

The cardiorespiratory examination should be performed with emphasis on findings relevant to assessing severity of exacerbations or to identify complications.

Laboratory studies in addition to pulmonary function tests which may be helpful include evaluation of inhalant allergy with skin tests or with in vitro tests (evaluation of inhalant allergy), complete blood count including eosinophil count, chest film, total IgE, sinus CT scan and sputum examination.

C. Diagnoses Other than Asthma - Differential diagnosis of asthma includes fixed airway obstruction (e.g., upper airway obstruction, lower airway obstruction such as from neoplasm), laryngeal dysfunction, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, emphysema, pulmonary parenchymal disorders (sarcoidosis, pulmonary fibrosis, others), bronchiectasis, cystic fibrosis, congestive heart failure, hyperventilation syndrome and pulmonary embolism.

D. Confirm Clinical Features are Consistent with Asthma - The diagnosis of asthma is based on the patient's medical history, physical examination, previous pulmonary function tests, and other laboratory test results.

E. Baseline Spirometry - All patients should undergo spirometry in the initial assessment of asthma. Spirometry detects the presence of airflow obstruction, defines the severity, and aids in the differential diagnosis of asthma. Particularly when performed before and after a bronchodilator, mild asthma is regularly detected when wheezing cannot be heard. This is especially useful when there is complaint of cough, dyspnea, or episodic wheezing. When spirometry is not available, a peak flow meter may be substituted. Peak flow meters are not interchangeable. Use the same meter if possible.

Testing should be performed in compliance with American Thoracic Society standards. Obstructive ventilatory defects can generally be determined using FEV1, FVC and FEV1/FVC ratio. To assess restrictive ventilatory defects, lung volumes are needed. 

TABLE OF EVIDENCE

Intervention References Grade of Evidence Strength of Recommendation
General guidelines and spirometry NAEPP, Expert Panel Report 2, 1997 1
Standardization of spirometry ATS 1991 C 1
Clinical evaluation of asthma Li et al. 1996 C 2a
Relation of pulmonary function tests to asthma Enright et al. 1994 B 2a
 
F. Airway Obstruction Demonstrated by FEV1/FVC < 0.7 or PEF < 75 Percent Predicted - Obstructive defects are characterized by a disproportionate reduction in FEV1 with respect to FVC. Airway obstruction may also result in a decrease in expiratory flow rates such as the FEF (25-75). If peak flow is normal, then airway obstruction may not be present.

TABLE OF EVIDENCE

Intervention References Grade of Evidence Strength of Recommendation
Pulmonary function testing ATS 1991 C 1
Asthma outcome related to pulmonary function Enright et al. 1994 C 2a
Peak flow criteria JTFPP 1995 B 2a
 
G. Administer Inhaled Short Acting Beta2-Agonist to Assess Reversibility - Following the administration of an aerosol bronchodilator, spirometry is repeated to assess the bronchodilator response. Patients who have been taking an intermediate acting bronchodilator prior to baseline spirometry need to discontinue the bronchodilator at least six hours prior to baseline spirometry. Patients need to discontinue taking long acting beta2-agonist 24 hours prior to baseline spirometry.

H. Improvement in FEV1 > 12 Percent and 200 ml - Failure to demonstrate a change with bronchodilator does not exclude a reversible component of obstruction.


TABLE OF EVIDENCE

Intervention References Grade of Evidence Strength of Recommendation
Interpretive strategies are useful in guiding therapy ATS 1991 

Enright et al. 1994 

 
I. Therapeutic Trial for 2 to 6 Weeks Using Inhaled Corticosteroids and/or Inhaled Short-Acting Beta2-Agonist - Patients with asthma who have demonstrated obstruction and do not demonstrate bronchodilator response may demonstrate improved pulmonary function following a therapeutic trial of 2 to 6 weeks. Therapeutic trial consists of inhaled corticosteroids, and/or oral corticosteroids, and/or inhaled beta2-agonist. Airway obstruction is considered reversible when PEF or FEV1 has increased > 20 percent after intensive therapy.

Peak expiratory flow rate (PEF) monitoring is a simple, reproducible measure of airway obstruction that can be obtained using an inexpensive portable peak flow meter. The patient should record PEF results in a peak flow diary. Peak flow diaries include a description of asthma symptoms, actions taken, medications used, and PEF. Significant improvement in PEF with asthma treatment supports the diagnosis of asthma.


TABLE OF EVIDENCE

Intervention References Grade of Evidence Strength of Recommendation
General guidelines NAEPP, Expert Panel Report 2, 1997  C 1
Value of peak flow monitoring Li 1995 

D'Alonzo et al. 1995 

Moscato et al. 1995

B 2a 
 
J. Peak Flow and/or FEV1 Increase > 20 Percent - Airway obstruction is considered reversible when PEF or FEV1 has increased > 20 percent after a therapeutic trial.

TABLE OF EVIDENCE

Intervention References Grade of Evidence Strength of Recommendation
Guideline for reversibility ATS 1991 

JTFPP 1995

C
 
K. Repeat Spirometry - Peak expiratory flow and examination are done to detect obstruction or wheezing on subsequent visits.

L. Episodic Obstruction Documented - Patients with mild asthma provoked primarily by exercise or environmental triggers may show normal pulmonary function when asymptomatic. Repeated measurements of FEV1 or PEF, particularly during symptoms, may be useful in these patients. Environmental triggers include pollen, dust, mites or animals, molds, occupational exposure, respiratory infection, or respiratory irritants (e.g., smoke). Presence of wheezing may also demonstrate obstruction or indicate asthma.


TABLE OF EVIDENCE

Intervention References Grade of Evidence Strength of Recommendation
Use of PEF Moscato et al. 1995 C 2a
Asthma outcome related to pulmonary function Enright et al. 1994 

Quackenboss et al. 1991

C 2a 
 
M. Bronchoprovocation Studies  - Do bronchoprovocation study (methacholine, exercise, cold air) with appropriate consultation. Patients with poorly defined symptoms should be considered for referral. Generally, an asthma specialist is a pulmonologist, allergist or internist with a specific knowledge and skill in the management of asthma. The specialist may consider a bronchoprovocation challenge test for patients with poorly defined symptoms or triggers, and normal baseline pulmonary function. Primary care providers may order such testing if they are experienced in the interpretation of test results.

This study should be done in an appropriate setting which is equipped for monitoring.


TABLE OF EVIDENCE

Intervention References Grade of Evidence Strength of Recommendation
Bronchoprovocation testing JTFPP 1995 

NAEPP, Expert Panel Report 2, 1997 

Enright et al. 1994

 
N. Evidence of Hyper-Responsiveness - There is a positive response to broncho-provocation study with reduction in FEV1.

TABLE OF EVIDENCE

Intervention References Grade of Evidence Strength of Recommendation
A reduction in FEV1 of 20 percent after bronchoprovocation indicates hyper-responsiveness  ATS 1991 

Enright et al. 1994

 
O. Assess Severity - The presence of one of the features of severity is sufficient to place a patient in that category. An individual should be assigned to the most severe grade in which any feature occurs. The characteristics noted in the algorithm are general and may overlap because asthma is highly variable. Furthermore, an individual's classification may change over time.

Patients at any level of severity can have mild, moderate, or severe exacerbations. Some patients with intermittent asthma may experience severe and life-threatening exacerbations separated by long periods of normal lung function and no symptoms.

P. Mild Intermittent Symptoms/Signs - Asymptomatic and normal PEF between exacerbations. Exacerbations are brief (from a few hours to a few days); intensity may vary. Nighttime symptoms < 2 times a month or symptoms < 2 times a week. Lung function: FEV1 or PEF > 80 percent predicted, PEF variability < 20 percent.


TABLE OF EVIDENCE

Intervention References Grade of Evidence Strength of Recommendation
Step classification system  NAEPP, Expert Panel Report 2, 1997  C 2a
 
Q. Step 1 Drug Therapy  - Therapy of Mild Intermittent Asthma. Long-term control: daily medication is not usually needed. For quick relief: short-acting bronchodilator (e.g., inhaled beta2-agonists) as needed for symptoms; intensity of treatment will depend on severity of exacerbation; use of short-acting inhaled beta2-agonists more than twice a week may indicate the need to initiate long-term control therapy.

TABLE OF EVIDENCE

Intervention References Grade of Evidence Strength of Recommendation
General guidelines NAEPP, Expert Panel Report 2, 1997  C 2a
Short-acting beta2-agonists Drazen et al. 1996 A 2a
 
R. Mild Persistent Asthma - Exacerbations may affect activity. Nighttime symptoms > 2 times a month or symptoms greater than 2 times a week but less than 1 time a day. Lung function: FEV1 or PEF > 80 percent predicted, PEF variability 20 to 30 percent.

See Annotation P for table of evidence.

S. Step 2 Drug Therapy - Therapy of mild persistent asthma. Long-term control with low dose inhaled corticosteroid. Other daily medication (e.g., inhaled cromolyn, nedocromil or leukotriene antagonists) may also be considered for patients >12 years of age, although their position in therapy is not fully established.

Quick relief: short-acting bronchodilator: inhaled short-acting beta2-agonist as needed for symptoms; intensity of treatment will depend on severity of exacerbation; and use of short-acting inhaled beta2-agonist on a daily basis or increasing use indicates the need for additional long-term control therapy.


ESTIMATED COMPARATIVE DAILY DOSAGES
FOR INHALED CORTICOSTEROIDS

Drug Low Dose Medium Dose High Dose
Beclomethasone 

dipropionate 

42 g/puff 

84 g/puff

168 to 504 g 

(4 to 12 puffs42 g) 

(2 to 6 puffs84 g)

504 to 840 g 

(12 to 20 puffs42 g) 

(6 to 10 puffs84 g)

> 840 g 

(> 20 puffs42 g) 

(> 10 puffs84 g) 

Budesonide Turbuhaler 

200 g/dose

200 to 400 g 

(1 to 2 inhalations)

400 to 600 g 

(2 to 3 inhalations)

> 600 g 

(> 3 inhalations) 

Flunisolide 

250 g/puff

500 to 1,000 g 

(2 to 4 puffs)

1,000 to 2,000 g 

(4 to 8 puffs)

> 2,000 g 

(> 8 puffs) 

Fluticasone 

MDI: 44, 110, 220 g/puff 

DPI: 50, 100, 250 g/puff

88 to 264 g 

(2 to 6 puffs44 g) or 

(2 puffs 110 g) 

(2 to 6 inhalations50 g)

264 to 660 g 

(2 to 6 puffs110 g) 

(3 to 6 inhalations 100 g)

> 660 g 

(> 6 puffs110 g) or 

(> 3 puffs220 g) 

(> 6 inhalations100 g) or > 2 inhalations250 g)

Triamcinolone acetonide 

100 g/puff

400 to 1,000 g 

(4 to 10 puffs)

1,000 to 2,000 g 

(10 to 20 puffs)

> 2,000 g 

(> 20 puffs) 

 

TABLE OF EVIDENCE

Intervention References Grade of Evidence Strength of Recommendation
General guidelines NAEPP, Expert Panel Report 2, 1997 C 2a
Inhaled corticosteroids Barnes et al. 1993 

Haahtela et al. 1991 

Haahtela et al. 1994

A
Cromolyn sodium and nedrocromil Lal et al. 1993 

Schwartz et al. 1996 

Cherniack et al. 1990

A 2a 
Methylxanthines Weinberger et al. 1996 C 2a
Leukotriene modifiers are effective in mild persistent asthma Israel et al. 1996 

Spector et al. 1994

A
Short-acting beta2-agonists: prn and regularly scheduled doses are equivalent Drazen et al. 1996 A 2a
 
T. Moderate Persistent Daily Signs/Symptoms - Daily use of inhaled short-acting beta2-agonist. Exacerbations affect activity. Exacerbations > 2 times a week and may last days. Nighttime symptoms > 1 time a week. Lung function: FEV1 or PEF > 60 percent to < 80 percent predicted, PEF variability > 30 percent.

See Annotation P for table of evidence.

U. Step 3 Drug Therapy - Therapy of moderate persistent asthma.

Long-term control: daily medication: either anti-inflammatory, inhaled corticosteroid (medium-dose), or inhaled corticosteroid (low-medium dose) and add a long-acting bronchodilator, especially for nighttime symptoms: either long-acting inhaled beta2-agonist, sustained-release theophylline, or long-acting beta2-agonist tablets. If needed: anti-inflammatory inhaled corticosteroids (medium-high dose) and long-acting bronchodilator, especially for nighttime symptoms, either long-acting inhaled beta2-agonist, sustained-release theophylline, or long-acting beta2-agonist tablets. See Annotation S for definitions of doses of inhaled corticosteroid.

Quick relief: Short-acting bronchodilator: inhaled beta2-agonist as needed for symptoms; intensity of treatment will depend on severity of exacerbation: use of short-acting inhaled beta2-agonist on a daily basis, or increasing use, indicates the need for additional long-term control therapy.

TABLE OF EVIDENCE
Also See Table of Evidence for Annotation S

Intervention References Grade of Evidence Strength of Recommendation
Long-acting beta2-agonist D'Alonzo et al. 1994 A 1
 
V. Severe Persistent Asthma - Limited physical activity. Frequent exacerbations. Frequent nighttime symptoms. Lung function: FEV1 or PEF < 60 percent predicted, PEF variability > 30 percent.

See Annotation P for table of evidence.

W. Step 4 Drug TherapyTherapy of severe persistent asthma.

Long-term control (daily medications). Anti-inflammatory: inhaled corticosteroid (high-dose) and long-acting bronchodilator: either long-acting inhaled beta2-agonist, sustained-release theophylline or long-acting beta2-agonist tablets and corticosteroid tablets or syrup long-term, (2mg/kg/day, generally do not exceed 60 mg per day).

Quick relief (short-acting bronchodilator). Inhaled short acting beta2-agonist as needed for symptoms; intensity of treatment will depend on severity of exacerbation; use of short-acting inhaled beta2-agonists on a daily basis, or increasing use, indicates the need for additional long-term control therapy. When respiratory failure is present or threatened, the use of intubation is regarded as appropriate therapy. See Emergency/Hospital Management of Asthma, Module C3.


TABLE OF EVIDENCE
Also See Table of Evidence for Annotation S

Intervention References Grade of Evidence Strength of Recommendation
Long-acting beta2-agonist D'Alonzo et al. 1994 A 1
 
X. Patient Education, Environmental Control, Objective Monitoring (FEV1 or PEF), Identify Coexisting Conditions - Patient education.

Patient education is essential for successful management of asthma. Patient education should occur at the first visit for asthma and continue. Critical education elements are: (a) Proficiency demonstration of MDI technique should be reassessed at every follow-up visit. (b) An Asthma Action Plan should be developed. Providers may be able to complete asthma education in collaboration with nursing and/or health education staff when available. Additional education elements may include: understanding basic pathophysiology of asthma and therapeutic mechanism of medications; early recognition and prompt treatment of asthma exacerbations; avoidance of important triggers; indications and adverse effects of medication; and PEF monitoring.

Asthma Action Plan: patients with mild asthma who have frequent exacerbations and all patients with moderate or severe asthma should have written Asthma Action Plans. Essential components include: current medications and dosages; warning signs and symptoms of impending exacerbations; PEF measurements; instructions for use of asthma medications during exacerbations; and instructions (including telephone numbers) for when and whom to call.

Environmental Control: providers should consider allergic triggers in all patients with asthma. Referral to asthma specialist for allergy evaluation (allergy testing) should be considered if significant allergic asthma is suspected. Patients with known allergic triggers should proceed with appropriate environmental control. Patients with allergic asthma should be considered for allergy immunotherapy.

Objective Monitoring: All patients with asthma should have periodic objective monitoring of airflow obstruction. Spirometry (measurement of FEV1) is the preferred test. Objective monitoring is also recommended at times of asthma exacerbations. Home peak flow diaries may be useful for patients with mild or moderate asthma who have frequent exacerbations. The diaries should include symptoms, actions taken, medications used, outcomes and PEF.

Identify Coexisting Conditions: gastroesophageal reflux; sinusitis/nasal polyps; medications which can aggravate asthma (e.g., aspirin, nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory agents, and beta blocking drugs including eye drops).


TABLE OF EVIDENCE

Intervention References Grade of Evidence Strength of Recommendation
General guidelines  NAEPP, Expert Panel Report 2, 1997  C 2a
Patient education and self management plan improves outcome in asthma Wilson et al. 1993 

Trautner et al. 1993 

Olsen 1991 

Bailey et al. 1990

Peak flow monitoring is effective in improving management of asthma Woolcock et al. 1988 

Ignacio-Garcia et al. 1995 

Lahdensuo et al. 1996 

Feder et al. 1995 

Parker 1989 

Beasley et al. 1989

Environmental control can reduce bronchial reactivity Platts-Mills et al. 1982 C 1
Immunotherapy is effective in selected patients with allergic asthma Abramson et al. 1995 A 1

Table of Contents | Module C2