|
Medical Nutrition Therapy
Medical Nutrition Therapy (MNT) is an initial, effective,
and low-cost approach to the management of patients with hypercholesterolemia
(McGehee et al., 1995). MNT is the
clinical nutrition assessment and the provision of appropriate nutrition
therapy by a registered dietitian or nutrition professional. A primary
care clinician should refer the patient for MNT. It has demonstrated effectiveness
for many diagnoses and has shown to be associated with a decrease in utilization
of health services (The Cost of Covering
MNT under TRICARE, 1998).
MNT includes review and analysis of a patient's medical
and dietary history, lab values, and anthropometric values. It is the
provision of appropriate nutrition therapy, to include skills training
for the patient, diet modification and outcomes-based counseling. The
benefits of MNT are lowered morbidity and progress towards positive health
outcomes (DCCT, 1993; Sikand
et al., 1996; Sikand et al., 1997).
MNT can lead to significant decrease in total cholesterol,
LDL-C and TG (Sikand et al., 1998;
Shaffer & Wexler, 1996; Shenberger
et al., 1992). In one study, 34 of 67 patients receiving MNT avoided
use of lipid medications, at an annual cost savings of $60,561; this study
demonstrated significant serum cholesterol reduction and health care dollar
savings with just three or four individualized MNT visits.
Often patients have multiple medical conditions, each
with specific dietary recommendations. MNT is an inexpensive and safe
intervention (McGehee et al., 1995;
Brannon et al., 1997; Stinnett
et al., 1996; Tosteson, et al., 1997;
Sheills et al., 1999; Splett,
1996). MNT teaches patients how to incorporate appropriate foods into
their current eating patterns, and how to make long-term diet changes.
MNT integrates information on food, nutrients, and meal preparation-consistent
with cultural background, socioeconomic status, and desired clinical outcomes-to
provide appropriate care (Medical Nutritional
Therapy, 1998).
Dietary change can significantly reduce total cholesterol
and LDL-C, and when part of an intensive lifestyle change program, can
slow the progression and may actually reverse the disease process (Haskell
et al, 1994; Ornish et al., 1990).
MNT is an intrinsic component of clinical practice and a shared responsibility
of the health care team. In the current managed care environment, we must
provide optimal health outcomes in the most economical way.
The MNT Protocol for Dyslipidemia
recommends three to four sessions, of 30 to 60 minutes in length.
ADDITIONAL INFORMATION: The following
guidelines are provided to assist those who do not have access to nutrition
professionals for MNT.
The primary focus of diet therapy for the prevention
and treatment of hypercholesterolemia is to progressively lower saturated
fatty acids (SFAs) and cholesterol at an energy level that facilitates
optimal weight management (See Table for Step I
and Step II diets). Other
diet modifications may be necessary for particular patient subgroups.
- Consumption of a diet in accordance with the NCEP/AHA
guidelines, starting with a Step I diet. In some individuals, a Step
II diet may be indicated, (NIH Consensus
Conference, 1993). For hypertriglyceridemia, the proportion of carbohydrate
to fat is controversial. However, the effect is attenuated in the context
of weight reduction and with the incorporation of high fiber foods,
(Tillotson et al. 1997; NIH
Consensus Conference, 1993).
- Complex carbohydrate and fiber should be emphasized
while restricting simple carbohydrate, (NIH
Consensus Conference, 1993).
- Weight reduction: Often weight loss can significantly
decrease plasma lipids and increase HDL-C levels, (NIH
Consensus Conference, 1993; NCEP
II, 1993).
- Restriction of alcohol: Small amounts can result
in fluctuations in serum triglycerides and should therefore be restricted
at least on a trial basis, (NCEP II,
1993).
Medical Nutrition Therapy Prescriptions
for High Blood Cholesterol
Medical Nutrition Therapy Prescriptions
for High Blood Cholesterol
|
Nutrient
|
Step I Diet
|
Step II Diet
|
|
Total Calories
|
To achieve and maintain desirable weight
|
|
Total Fat
|
30% or less of total caloriesa
|
|
Saturated Fatty Acids
|
8-10% of total calories
|
< than 7% of total calories
|
|
Polyunsaturated Fatty Acids
|
Up to 10% of total calories
|
|
Monounsaturated Fatty Acids
|
Up to 15% of total calories
|
|
Carbohydrates
|
55% or more of total calories
|
|
Protein
|
Approximately 15% of total calories
|
|
Cholesterol
|
Less than 300 mg/day
|
Less than 200 mg/day
|
Adapted from NCEP
II, 1993
a Often this guideline is misinterpreted to mean
that each (single) food item should be less than 30 percent fat. The guideline
applies to total calories eaten over several days. Applying the 30 percent
rule to single food items would exclude many appropriate food choices.
Although Step I and Step II diets are frequently referenced as initial
therapies, individualization based on nutritional assessment, BMI, co-morbidities,
lifestyle and lipid reduction goal is essential for appropriate care.
Patients eat foods, not nutrients. The MNT prescriptions must be translated
into foods to be meaningful for patients (see patient education references).
It is important to provide ongoing support and reinforcement
to patients undertaking significant dietary changes. This can take several
forms, including follow-up visits, telephone calls, and postcards. It
is important to encourage patients through the plateaus and regressions
that occur as a normal part of efforts at long-term change (USDHHS,
Clinician's Handbook, 1998).
Examples of foods to choose or
decrease for the NCEP Step I and Step II Diets
Examples of foods to choose or decrease for the NCEP Step I and Step II Diets
|
Food Group
|
Choose
|
Decrease
|
Lean meat, poultry, and fish

5-6 ounces per day
|
Beef, pork, lamb lean cuts well trimmed
before cooking
Poultry w/o skin
Fish, shellfish
Processed meats prepared from lean meats, e.g., lean ham, lean frankfurters,
lean meat with soy protein or carrageen |
Regular hamburger, fatty cuts of beef,
spare ribs, organ meats
Poultry with skin, fried chicken
Fried fish, fried shellfish
Regular luncheon meat (bologna, salami, sausage, frankfurters) |
Eggs

4 egg yolks per week, Step I

2 egg yolks per week, Step II
|
Egg whites, cholesterol-free egg whites |
Egg yolks (if more than the recommended);
includes eggs used in baking and cooking |
|
Low-fat dairy products
|
Milk skim ½% or 1% fat (fluid,
powdered, evaporated, buttermilk)
Yogurt non-fat or low-fat yogurt or yogurt beverages |
Whole milk, regular yogurt (fluid,
evaporated, condensed), 2% milk, imitation milk
Whole milk yogurt |
|
Dairy products
|
Cheese low-fat natural or processed
cheese
Low-fat or nonfat varieties, e.g., cottage cheese-low-fat, nonfat,
or dry curd 0% to 2%)
Frozen dairy dessert ice milk, frozen yogurt (low-fat or nonfat)
Low-fat coffee creamer
Low-fat or nonfat sour cream |
Regular cheeses (American blue, Brie,
cheddar, Colby, Edam, Monterey Jack, whole-milk mozzarella, Parmesan
, Swiss), cream cheese, Neufchatel cheese
Cottage cheese (4% milkfat)
Ice cream
Cream, half & half, whipping cream
Non-dairy creamer, whipped topping, sour cream |
Fats and Oils

6-8 teaspoons per day
|
Unsaturated oils safflower, sunflower,
corn, soybean, cottonseed, canola, olive, peanut
Margarines made from unsaturated oils listed above, especially soft
or liquid forms
Salad dressings made with unsaturated oils, low-fat or fat-free
Seeds and nuts peanut butter, other nut butters
Cocoa powder |
Coconut oil, palm kernel oil, palm
oil
Butter, lard, shortening, bacon fat, hard margarine
Dressings made with egg yolk, cheese, sour cream, whole milk
Coconut
Milk chocolate |
|
Breads and cereals
|
Breads whole-grain bread, English muffins,
bagels, buns, corn or flour tortilla
Cereal oat, wheat, corn, multi-grain
Pasta
Rice
Dry beans and peas
Crackers, low-fat animal type, graham, soda crackers, breadsticks,
melba toast
Homemade baked goods using unsaturated oil, skim or 1% milk, and egg
substitute quick breads, biscuits, cornbread muffins, bran muffins,
pancakes, waffles |
Bread in which eggs, fat, and/or butter
are a major ingredient; croissants
Most granolas
High-fat crackers
Commercial baked pastries, muffins, biscuits |
|
Soups
|
Reduced or low-fat and reduced sodium
varieties, e.g., chicken or beef noodle, minestrone, tomato, vegetable,
potato, reduced-fat soups made with skim milk |
Soup containing whole milk, cream,
meat fat, poultry fat, or poultry skin |
|
Vegetables
3-5 servings per day
|
Fresh, frozen, or canned, without added
fat or sauce |
Vegetables fried or prepared with butter,
cheese, or cheese sauce |
|
Fruits
2-4 servings per day
|
Fruit fresh, frozen, canned or dried
Fruit juice fresh, frozen or canned |
Fried fruit or fruit served with butter
or cream sauce |
|
Sweets and modified fat desserts
Use cautiously if weight loss is recommended or with hypertriglyceridemia
|
Beverages fruit fruit-flavored
drinks, lemonade, fruit punch
Sweets sugar, syrup, honey, jam, preserves, candy made without added
fat (candy corn, gumdrops, hard candy), fruit flavored gelatin
Frozen dessert low-fat and nonfat yogurt, ice milk, sherbet, sorbet,
fruit ice, popsicles
Cookies, cake, pie, pudding prepared with egg whites, egg substitutes,
skim milk or 1% milk, and unsaturated oil or margarine; ginger snaps,
fig and other fruit bar cookies, fat-free cookies, angel food cake |
Candy made with milk chocolate, coconut
oil, palm kernel oil, palm oil
Ice cream and frozen treats made with ice cream
Commercial baked pies, cakes, doughnuts, high-fat cookies, cream pies |
From USDHHS, Clinician's
Handbook, 1998
Note: Careful selection of processed foods is necessary to stay within
the sodium guideline (< 2400 mg).
These represent general guidelines, which will need to be individualized
for patients based on lipid profile, co-morbidities, and treatment goals.
Specific Foods as Non-pharmacologic Therapy
Consumers and health care professionals alike are increasingly interested
in the use of functional foods (nutritious foods that contain specific
ingredients that aid with specific physiological functions). Consumers
are interested in non-pharmacologic ways to prevent diseases. Below is
a summary of the more recognized nutrients, their potential benefits,
and practical application.
Nutrients with Strong Supportive
Clinical Evidence
Nutrients with Strong Supportive
Clinical Evidence
|
Specific Food
|
Potential Benefit
|
Concerns
|
Practical Advice
|
|
Fish Oil and Fish Oil Supplements*
|
TG levels
Effects on other lipids variable
Protective against CVD
thrombus
formation |
Monitor if on anticoagulant therapy
Fish oil capsules may contribute to vitamins A and D toxicity
Some preparations lack vitamin E; concern for oxidation
Capsules expensive |
Eat fish at least once a week, especially varieties
high in n-3 fatty acids
(salmon, sardines, mackerel) |
|
Plant Sterols and Stanols
|
Shown to LDL
10-20% |
|
Include plant stanol ester foods into daily diet,
substituted for foods
of similar fat content |
* GISSI, 1999
Other Nutrients
Other Nutrients
|
Specific Food
|
Potential Benefit
|
Concerns
|
Practical Advice
|
|
Vitamin E
|
Reduces risk of CVD
Reduces platelet aggregation
Reduces thrombus formation
Prevents unwanted oxidation |
Caution with anticoagulant therapy
Difficult to obtain therapeutic amounts via foods alone |
400-800 IU/day appears safe
Food sources include vegetable oils, dark green leafy vegetables,
nuts, avocados, whole grain cereals, fortified cereals |
|
Beta Carotene(most abundant and biologically active
carotenoid)
|
Anti-oxidant properties |
High doses may discolor skin
Extent of risk reduction still unclear |
Advise patients to get beta carotene
via diet, consuming at least 5 servings of fruits/vegetables, especially
leafy green and yellow vegetables (spinach, kale, carrots, yellow
squash, broccoli) |
|
Vitamin C
|
Works with vitamin E and beta carotene
to prevent cellular oxidation
Effectiveness in decreasing risk of CVD is questionable |
May cause abdominal bloating and diarrhea
have been reported if > 2 g are consumed |
Optimal intake difficult to assess,
although probably in range of 180-750 (mg).
Best food sources include citrus fruits, strawberries, broccoli, green
peppers, tomatoes and potatoes |
|
Soy Protein
|
Phytoestrogens in soybeans appear to
reduce arthogenicity of LDL |
No large multi-center, long-term clinical
studies have tested safety nor effectiveness, although FDA has recently
approved health claim for soy protein: "25 grams of soy protein
per day may reduce risk of heart disease" |
Low-fat soy foods are appropriate addition,
especially if high cholesterol.
Food sources include tofu, soybeans, soynuts, soy milk, and soy cheese |
|
Garlic
|
Modest reduction cholesterol, LDL-cholesterol,
and TG
Antithrombotic properties |
Considerable variability across studies
Can't identify who and what conditions would benefit most
Odor |
Prudent to recommend eating a variety
of foods and not to restrict garlic intake |
From Medical Nutrition,
1998
References for Tables:
1. Cater, N. B. (1999). Plant
stanol ester foods: new tools in the dietary management of cholesterol.
Nutrition and the MD, 25(11)
2. Merritt, R. J. (1999). Soy
Protein Health Claim Gets FDA Authorization.
Nutrition and the MD, 25(11)
References for patient education/nutrition/self-management programs:
3. The American Dietetic Association's Nationwide Nutrition Network
is a national referral service that links consumers, physicians, food
manufacturers, distributors or restaurant owners or managers with registered
dietitians. All Participants in the American Dietetic Association's Nationwide
Nutrition Network (dietitian referral service) are registered dietitians-professionals
who provide reliable, objective nutrition information, separate facts
from fads and translate the latest scientific findings into easy-to-understand
nutrition information. The web site address is http://www.eatright.org/find.html.
|